Wednesday, September 22, 2010
Debate & Deliberation
Debate and Deliberation are great strategies to incorporate into the social studies classroom. Both teach students how to research a topic, formulate/defend a position, and present a point of view. However, both strategies are not exactly the same. Provide a definition that explains their differences.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Deliberation occurs when something needs to be accomplished and people work together through discussion to come to one answer.
ReplyDeleteDebate occurs when there are two (or more) opposing viewpoints and people go back and forth (sometimes as an argument) to decide which answer is the best.
Debate is an issue that has to have more than one side or position that the students can discuss and explore. In debate students would more than likely be divided into at least two groups that each have a position on the issue. Deliberation is an issue that the whole class can explore together. It doesn't always have to have more than one position students take on it, however it needs to be an issue that students can explore in depth.
ReplyDeleteDebate includes two opposing views and people argue either sside back and forth. Deliberation is talking through issues with one another.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is when people work together to come up with one solution
ReplyDeleteDebate is when two or more opposite view points go back and forth on an issue to decide the best solution
Deliberation is when people work together to come to a common stand point.
ReplyDeleteDebate is when two people discuss different view points about a similar topic, and try to stress their view point as the correct one.
A debate is involves two opposing sides who go against each other in an attempt to win a presented issue. It usually involves tension.
ReplyDeleteTp deliberate is to try to to come together in trying to settle on one issue. This is more of a unilateral setting in which there isnt a real "battle" against one another.
A debate usually occurs between two people that have differing points of view. These people will work against one another to show their point of view as the right one.
ReplyDeleteA deliberation allows people to work together to come to a common point of views.
Deliberation occurs when more than one person works together to come to a solution or consensus.
ReplyDeleteDebate occurs when two people go back and forth discussing a specific topic or for a specific purpose.
Debate is when there are two different viewpoints that people discuss and then come up with the best possible answer. Deliberation is when people talk through an issue to come up with one common answer.
ReplyDeleteDebate is when two people or groups have two different viewpoints.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is when a group works together to decide the best solution.
debate defends original solutions. Deliberation opens the possibility of better solutions.
ReplyDeleteDebate involves two opposing sides. Each side goes back and forth within a given amount of time. Sometimes there is more than one side, but this doesn't seem to happen a lot.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is more of working together to accomplish a common goal. For example, the jury was a group of people working together to decide on whether someone in a case is guilty or not.
Deliberation is a group of people coming together to come to an agreement about a common or problem. Debate is when two or more opposing sides go back and forth on the issues.
ReplyDeleteDebating is when you all ready have your mind made up about the issue. Deliberating is when you are contemplating on which way you want to go!
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is using discussion about an issue to come to an agreement and debate is two opposing views discussing something
ReplyDeleteDebates take place when there are opposing sides, arguing for or against an issue. Deliberations occur inorder to reach a consensus on an issue.
ReplyDeleteA debate allows for a difference in opinion to an open discussion, where deliberation comes to a conclusion during discussion.
ReplyDeleteDebating is when two people are going back and forth on a topic and each person is not going to change their mind on tier view. Deliberation is trying to come to the same conclusion.
ReplyDeleteDebate is more of an argument (however civilized or uncivilized is up to the participants) between two sides where each side holds a certain opinion. Deliberation is when a group of people work together to talk about a problem in order to come to a common solution.
ReplyDeleteA debate is when you hold fast to your side and defend it from opposing points of view.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is where you look at different views and reach a common ground
debate is when multiple sides to an issue go back and forth arguing that their point of view is correct.
ReplyDeletedeliberation is when you are discussing the options for an agreement
Debate is when people hold two different opinions on a topic, and are arguing that their side it right. Deliberation is when people are coming together to make a joint decision on something
ReplyDeleteDeliberation focuses upon a issue or problem that is discussed until a solution is found. While Debate represents two sides that have a specific opinion and are trying to convince each other of a certain point of view.
ReplyDeleteDebate is when people have different viewpoints and are trying to explain why their ideas are right.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is when people come together to come up with an agreement.
A debate is when two opposing views are argued, when a person tries to express their point of view as better than the opposing. Deliberation is when ideas are explored and discussed to come to a decision about something.
ReplyDeleteTo debate is to already have your mind made up about a situation and aruging about opposite views and opinions. Both parties will not come to the same conclusion.
ReplyDeleteDelibration is compromising and working out a solution between two opposite views.
A debate has two or more sides being argued for. Deliberation is when everyone argues in order to reach one agreement.
ReplyDeleteDebate is two different sides trying to prove which side id better/right. They communicate by arguing for their side over their opposition.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is a group working together to come to make a decision.
Debate is when there are two opposing people fighting for what he/she wants/believes in.
ReplyDeleteDeliberation is when there are a group of people discussing an issue and have to come to a conclusion on a decision.